Vertical Integration: What It Is, Why It Matters, and How to Do It Right

Image created with Bing Image Creator

What is vertical integration?

Vertical integration is a firm’s ownership and control of multiple vertical stages in the supply of a product. The extent of a firm’s vertical integration is indicated by the number of stages of the industry’s value chain that it spans, and can be measured by the ratio of its value added to sales revenue.

Vertical integration can be either backward (or upstream) into its suppliers’ activities or forward (or downstream) into its customers’ activities. Upstream refers to activities closer to distribution (think making the raw materials) whereas downstream refers to activities closer to the market (think marketing, launching a product to the market). Vertical integration may also be full or partial. VI refers to the change in scope of activities that are under the firm’s control.

Why vertical integration?

One of the main reasons for adopting vertical integration is to reduce transaction costs, which refer to the cost a firm will have to pay another firm for a service. If a firm has many suppliers, they would have high transaction costs.

Vertical integration lowers transaction costs due to the fact that a single firm could produce everything themselves. However, vertical integration may also impose administrative costs instead. Therefore, firms need to compare their internal and external transaction costs and decide whether vertical integration is worth it or not.

Another reason for adopting vertical integration is to cope with uncertainty in supply, demand, technology, and competition. Uncertainty can increase transaction costs and reduce efficiency and quality in production. By integrating vertically, firms can have more control over their inputs and outputs, reduce their dependence on external parties, and increase their responsiveness and adaptability to changing market conditions.

A third reason for adopting vertical integration is to gain competitive advantage by creating differentiation, increasing efficiency, enhancing quality, or capturing more value from customers or suppliers. By integrating vertically, firms can leverage their core competencies, exploit economies of scale or scope, improve coordination and communication across functions or stages, or access valuable resources or capabilities that are otherwise unavailable or costly.

What are the benefits and challenges?

Vertical integration can bring several benefits for firms, such as:

• Improved data quality and availability: By integrating information systems across different levels and stages of production, firms can collect and process more accurate and timely data that can support decision-making and optimization.
• Increased operational efficiency and flexibility: By integrating production processes across different stages or functions, firms can reduce waste, improve coordination, streamline workflows, automate tasks, and adjust production parameters according to demand or product specifications.
• Enhanced product quality and innovation: By integrating product design and development with production processes, firms can ensure consistency between design specifications and actual outcomes, improve feedback loops, enable rapid prototyping and testing, and foster creativity and experimentation.
• Greater customer satisfaction and loyalty: By integrating customer-facing activities with production processes, firms can offer more customized products or services, provide faster delivery or response times, improve after-sales service or support, and build stronger relationships with customers.
• Higher profitability and market share: By integrating value-adding activities across different stages of production or distribution, firms can capture more value from customers or suppliers, reduce costs, increase revenues, or create entry barriers for competitors.
• Gaining more control: By vertically integrating, firms can gain more control over their supply chain. They would ensure that each chain in their business would work towards the same goal, thus avoiding e.g. gaming problems or increased prices from external suppliers.

However, vertical integration also poses some challenges for firms, such as:

• Higher investment costs and risks: By integrating multiple stages or functions of production, firms need to invest more in capital, technology, or human resources, and face higher risks of failure or obsolescence.
• Reduced focus and flexibility: By integrating activities that are not part of their core competencies, firms may lose focus on their main strengths or sources of differentiation, and become less flexible or responsive to changing customer needs or market opportunities.
• Increased complexity and coordination costs: By integrating information systems and production processes across different levels and stages, firms may face increased complexity and coordination costs due to the need for interoperability, standardization, or alignment of data, systems, or processes.
• Potential conflicts of interest or goals: By integrating activities that involve different stakeholders or objectives, firms may encounter potential conflicts of interest or goals between different functions or units, such as between R&D and production, or between production and sales.

What are some examples?

Vertical integration can be applied in different industries and sectors, such as IT, technology, and AI. Here are some examples of successful cases of vertical integration in these domains:

• Apple: Apple is one of the most well-known examples of vertical integration in the IT industry. Apple designs, develops, manufactures, and sells its own hardware and software products, such as the iPhone, iPad, Mac, Apple Watch, AirPods, iOS, macOS, iCloud, and Apple Music. By integrating vertically, Apple can ensure high quality and compatibility across its products, create a unique user experience, differentiate itself from competitors, and capture more value from customers.
• Tesla: Tesla is another example of vertical integration in the technology industry. Tesla designs, manufactures, sells, and services its own electric vehicles, batteries, solar panels, and charging stations. By integrating vertically, Tesla can control the quality and performance of its products, reduce its dependence on suppliers, lower its costs, innovate faster, and offer more value to customers.
• OpenAI: OpenAI is an example of vertical integration in the AI industry. OpenAI is a research organization that aims to create artificial general intelligence (AGI), which is AI that can perform any intellectual task that humans can. OpenAI develops its own AI systems and platforms, such as GPT-3, DALL-E, Codex, and OpenAI Codex. By integrating vertically, OpenAI can pursue its vision of creating AGI that is aligned with human values and can benefit humanity.

Conclusion

Vertical integration can be a key strategy for firms that can bring many benefits to firms in different industries and sectors. However, vertical integration also involves some challenges and trade-offs that firms need to consider carefully before implementing it.

Firms need to assess their internal and external transaction costs, their sources of uncertainty, their competitive advantage, and their goals and objectives when deciding whether to integrate vertically or not. Vertical integration is not a one-size-fits-all solution, but a strategic choice that depends on the context and circumstances of each firm.